Are Casper’s Mattresses Worth the Money? (Pros v Cons)

Casper is one of the most popular mattress companies at the moment.

But is a Casper mattress worth the money?

A Casper mattress is worth the money if you’re looking for a high-quality memory foam, polyfoam, or hybrid mattress that sleeps relatively cool, can ease aches and pains, and is suitable for a wide range of sleeping styles because they are fairly priced and can outlast many cheaper mattresses.

The rest of this article considers the pros and cons of Casper’s mattresses in more detail and looks at the pricing of each model relative to the rest of the mattress market to help you decide if a Casper mattress really is the right choice for you.

Alternatively: if you don’t want to buy a Casper mattress, then check out some of the best mattresses that you can buy online here.

Should You Buy a Casper Mattress?

You should consider buying a Casper mattress if any of their Casper Original, Casper Original Hybrid, Casper Wave Hybrid, Casper Nova Hybrid, or Casper Element models meet your specific sleeping requirements because although these mattresses may cost more than some of the cheaper alternatives available, the quality of the materials means that your Casper mattress could last longer and feel more comfortable.

To help you decide if you should pay for a Casper mattress, I’ve summarized the main pros and cons of their entire mattress range below – with mention of specific models where appropriate to help you narrow down your selection.

Pros

Below is a list if the 10 potential benefits of buying a Casper mattress:

1: Collectively Suitable For All Sleeper Types

When you consider the entire Casper mattress range, they collectively are able to meet the needs of just about every sleeping position and style.

Here’s a summary review of each of Casper’s mattress models relative to their ideal sleeper types:

• Casper Original (all-foam) – a medium-firm mattress made from memory foam and polyfoam that’s best for couples, side sleepers, back sleepers, front sleepers, lighter weighted sleepers, and sleepers with a low body fat percentage.

• Casper Hybrid (spring + foam) – a medium-firm mattress with a polyfoam and memory foam top layer and a spring support core that’s best for warmer sleepers, restless sleepers, combination sleepers, and heavier-weighted sleepers; as well as front, side, and back sleepers.

• Casper Nova Hybrid (spring + foam) – a medium-soft mattress with a polyfoam and memory foam upper layer and a spring support core that’s best for side sleepers, edge, sleepers, and warmer sleepers.

• Casper Wave Hybrid (spring + foam) – a medium mattress with a polyfoam and memory foam upper layer and a spring core that’s best for those with back pain and muscular discomfort; as well as front, back, side, and combination sleepers (including couples).

• Casper Element (all-foam) – a medium-firm mattress made entirely from polyfoam that’s best for sleepers shopping on a budget and couples; as well as front, back, side, and combination sleepers.

2: Use With a Wide Range of Frame Types

Casper also sells a range of bed frames – such as the Adjustable Frame, Adjustable Pro, Platform Frame, Upholstered Frame, Foundation, Haven Bed Frame, and Repose Bed Frame – that can each either be used with all or some of Casper’s mattresses.

Check the Bed Frame tab to see the exact compatibility specs (it’s under the ‘compatibility’ toggle box) or simply click the ‘+’ button on the mattress order page to add the compatible frame of your choice to your cart and then check out.

3: Sleeps Cooler Than Other Memory Foam Mattresses

Memory foam mattresses are infamous for sleeping hot and making you sweat.

And whilst all of Casper’s mattresses except the Casper Element contain memory foam, the foam construct and layering design means that you’re less likely to overheat in a Casper mattress.

More specifically, the memory foam is layered underneath an Airscape™ Foam top layer that’s specifically designed to allow for heat dissipation and breathability, whilst the hybrid versions are even better at regulating your temperature because the spacious coil core allows the air to flow through the mattress more freely.

So if you’re a warmer sleeper then don’t let the fact that Casper’s mattresses contain memory foam put you off.

4: Ideal For Couples

All of Casper’s mattresses have some qualities that makes them ideal for couples.

For example, the all-foam designs of the Casper Original and the Casper Element allows them to effectively absorb the movements caused by you and your partner better than a regular spring mattress can for reduced disturbance.

And if you go for one of Casper’s hybrid mattresses then you can still expect good cross-mattress and vertical motion isolation because unlike a regular spring mattress that uses a connected coil core, the individually wrapped coils are far superior when it comes to dissipating shock waves.

5: Ease Aches and Pains

All of Casper’s mattresses contain foam that can help to soften the pressure created when your body comes into contact with the mattress, with the memory foam sub-layers of the respective models amplifying this effect thanks to the material’s ability to conform more precisely to your individual body shape than the upholstered layer of a traditional spring mattress can.

The Casper Wave Hybrid is the stand-out model when it comes to combating back pain because it leverages zoned support and gel pods to help alleviate pressure and keep you in good posture.

6: Budget Option Available

The Casper Element is Casper’s cheapest mattress – presently costing less than $600 for a queen (with further discounts often available).

This makes the Casper Element a serious contender if you’re looking for a high-quality all-foam mattress on a budget.

7: Excellent Pressure Relief

The combination of proprietary foam and memory foam used in Casper’s mattresses allows them to excel at alleviating pressure on the more angular regions of your body whilst also removing pressure from your joints by dissipating your body weight more evenly across the surface of the mattress.

8: 100-Night Sleep Trial

As good as Casper’s mattresses are, there’s always the slim chance that you’re uncomfortable even after the initial break-in period has passed (around 30 nights of continuous use).

That’s why Casper offers a 100-night sleep trial so that you can return the mattress and get a full refund if you’re unhappy with it for any reason.

9: 10-Year Warranty

All of Casper’s mattresses come with a 10-year limited warranty to cover you in the unlikely event of you buying a defective mattress.

10: 0% APR Financing

If you’re sold on the idea of a Casper mattress but you don’t want to pay in full up-front then you can apply for financing with Affirm at the checkout for the chance to spread the cost at 0% APR to increase affordability.

Cons

Here are a few things to consider before you buy your Casper mattress:

1: Mild Off-Gassing

Upon unboxing your new Casper mattress, you may notice an ‘off-gassing’ smell due to the particles that were trapped during packaging being released.

This is common to pretty much all compressed mattresses in a box and the smell should dissipate in a few hours or days (make sure to keep your room well aired in the meantime).

2: Cooler Mattresses Are Available

Whilst Casper’s mattresses don’t tend to sleep hot and can actually help to regulate your temperature, you may want to consider a hybrid natural latex mattress with springs if maximum cooling capabilities are your primary concern.

How Much Does a Casper Mattress Cost?

A Casper mattress costs between $595 and $2595 (without discounts) for a queen size.

Below is a table that lists the exact cost of a Casper mattress in queen for each model at the time of writing:

Are Casper’s Mattresses Cheaper than Other Mattresses?

Casper’s mattresses are, for the most part, cheaper than the average price ranges for comparable mattress types in the context of the online mattress market – with Casper’s top models falling into the upper-mid and lower-upper price brackets when no discounts are applied.

For example, based on the table below (compiled through my own personal research of mattress prices online), you can see that Casper’s Element model falls below even the typical lowest price point of $600 for an all-foam mattress.

Whilst at $1095, Casper’s higher-end Original model falls in the mid-price range and just a touch above the average price point of $1000 for this type of all-foam model.

And the Casper Original Hybrid comes in at the lower end of the low price bracket at $1295 to significantly undercut the $1750 average price point.

The Casper Nova Hybrid sits within the mid-price range and the top-spec Casper Wave Hybrid creeps just beyond the mid-price bracket at $2595.

However, for all models, keep in mind that Casper often run generous discounts that can save you $100s and push the costs down even further for you.

How Does Casper Compare to Other Mattresses?

You can expect Casper’s mattresses to be of higher quality, last longer, and have the potential for better comfort and support when compared to many cheaper and lower quality mattresses on the market, with some specific types of natural latex and hybrid mattresses potentially being more suitable for certain sleeping requirements like maximum cooling capabilities.

Below is a more detailed explanation of how Casper’s mattresses stack up against different types of mattresses:

1: Casper vs Cheap Memory Foam Mattresses

Casper’s mattresses are likely to outperform most other cheap memory foam and polyfoam mattresses because Casper uses a proprietary blend of high-density foams to increase durability, guard against sagging, and increase the overall lifespan of the mattress.

And to the best of my knowledge, based on my extensive research, Casper’s mattresses DON’T contain fiberglass – which means that you won’t have to worry about this harmful substance being released into your home where it can cause health problems and cost $1,000s to remove.

(Fiberglass is commonly found in cheap memory foam mattresses as part of the fire barrier to meet flammability standards in a cost-effective way).

Therefore, I would personally feel happier buying the Casper Original mattress over cheaper memory foam mattresses on the market because there’s no fiberglass to worry about and the mattress will probably last longer.

But if the cost is an issue, then I would go for the all-foam Casper Element because although this mattress only contains polyfoam, it’s still high quality and very affordable.

2: Casper vs Cheap Spring Mattresses

Casper’s hybrid mattresses are likely to be superior to most cheap innerspring mattresses on the market simply because Casper uses higher quality materials and has individually wrapped coils to help isolate movement, provide more adaptive support, and increase the lifespan of the mattress.

3: Casper vs Latex Mattresses

When it comes to pressure relief, Casper’s mattresses may indeed have the edge over many latex foam mattresses due to the exceptional ability of the memory foam to mold to your exact body shape.

However, if you’re looking for the most cooling mattress possible and/or need a highly responsive mattress with extra bounce that allows you to switch positions with ease then you may be better going for a hybrid spring mattress with a natural latex foam top layer.

However, expect to pay much more for mattresses that contain a high percentage of natural latex (especially if the latex is certified as organic by GOLS).

4: Casper vs Hybrid Mattresses

Casper’s hybrid mattresses are at least equal and potentially superior to many of the other big brand hybrid mattresses on the market due to the high-quality proprietary memory foam blends that they use to enhance the cooling and pressure-relieving qualities of the upper comfort layers.

Related Questions

With the core of the content now covered, I’m going to round-off this post with the concise answers to some of the most commonly asked questions related to Casper’s mattresses.

Is a Casper Mattress Good For Your Back?

A Casper mattress can be good for your back if you choose the right level of firmness relative to your dominant sleeping position, body weight, and physical characteristics (although back pain is possible if you choose the wrong specifications) – the Casper Wave is specifically designed to help sleepers with back pain sleep more comfortably.

Is a Casper Mattress Good For Side Sleepers?

Casper’s mattresses are good for side sleepers because the foam in the upper comfort layers is designed to adapt to your shoulders and hips to reduce pressure points – the best Casper mattress for side sleepers is the Casper Nova because it has a softer feel for even greater pressure relief.

Is a Casper Mattress Hot?

Casper’s mattresses are not necessarily hot to sleep on because they come with breathable Airscape™ Foam in the upper layers whilst the hybrid models can increase airflow and maximize heat dissipation to help regulate your temperature effectively.

Conclusion: A Worthy Investment

Given that Casper’s mattresses chiefly fall in-line or below the average price points relative to each category of mattresses on the market, buying a Casper mattress could be a worthy investment because the higher quality materials and enhanced durability may mean that you get more life out of your mattress and thus reduce the relative cost of sleep per night over the long run.

However, if you’ve decided that a Casper mattress isn’t worth the money then you can click the button below to see a selection of the best mattresses to buy online now.

Image Attribution and Licencing

All images provided by Casper.com used with permission under the terms of a private affiliate agreement.

Dan

Dan is the founder and head content creator at Bedroom Style Reviews.

He has been working as a professional online product reviewer since 2015 and was inspired to start this website when he ended up sleeping on a memory foam mattress that was too soft and gave him backache.

Through in-depth research and analysis, Dan’s goal with this website is to help others avoid such pitfalls by creating the best online resource for helping you find your ideal mattress, bedding, and bedroom furniture.

Dan is a qualified NVQ Level 2 Fitness Instructor with 6 years’ experience helping clients improve their health through diet, exercise, and proper sleep hygiene.

He also holds several college and university-level qualifications in health sciences, psychology, mathematics, art, and digital media creation – which helps him to publish well researched and informative product reviews as well as articles on sleep, health, wellbeing, and home decor.

Dan also has direct personal experience with insomnia, anxiety, misophonia (hypersensitivity to sounds), and pain from both acute and long-standing sporting injuries – he enjoys writing insightful articles around these subjects to help fellow sufferers of such conditions.

Learn more about Dan here.