Many people prefer to buy their mattress in person.
Because by attending a showroom, you can test the mattress out first-hand to see if it’s comfortable for you.
The downside is that these mattresses can be very expensive – with cheaper alternatives often being available online.
But how can you find your ideal mattress without first trying it out?
Well, if you’re looking to buy online, then the most effective thing that you can do is to check out my guide to choosing the right mattress firmness.
Where I walk you through the process of finding the right mattress for you based on your sleeping position, body weight, accommodating for your bed partner, the mattress materials, and any pain that you might have.
But there’s one thing that I didn’t talk about in that guide:
Indentation load deflection.
Because in my opinion, indentation load deflection isn’t an accurate way to gauge possible mattress firmness and comfort.
What is Indentation Load Deflection?
In the most basic sense, indentation load deflection (ILD) is a measurement of how ‘hard’ or ‘soft’ a foam mattress is.
More specifically, ILD is a value that expresses the amount of force required to compress different types of foam through a specific type of test that I’ve detailed for you below.
This test is used in a range of industries to measure the firmness, stiffness, or load bearing capacity of things that contain foam – like car seats and furniture in addition to mattresses.
Image source: stock photo used with permission.
ILD vs IFD
The term ‘indentation load deflection’ (ILD) is often used interchangeably with that of ‘indentation force deflection’ (IFD).
And for practical purposes, you can take the two to mean the same thing when looking at ILD values.
The alternate terminology is simply a reflection of the differences between the imperial and metric systems.
How is ILD Measured?
ILD is calculated by taking a section of the foam measuring 100 mm in thickness – with an area of 500 mm by 500 mm – to which a flat, circular indenter with a surface area of 323 cm squared is applied .
The indenter is depressed into the foam until an indent of 25% of the foam is achieved – at which point a force reading is taken after 60 seconds.
Ratings are then expressed in pounds/force (US) or newtons (EU).
What Do the ILD Ratings Mean?
The bottom line is that a ‘lower’ ILD rating indicates a softer foam, whilst a ‘higher’ ILD rating maps to a harder foam.
ILD ratings are typically expressed as a range.
So in theory, you could potentially use ILD ratings to figure out how firm your mattress is likely to be.
And I’ve created the table below so that you can see how various ILD ratings might correlate to potential mattress firmnesses.
But the reality of the matter is that different ILD ratings could correspond to totally different firmnesses.
I’ll explain why in the next section.
|ILD Rating (lbs)||Possible Mattress Firmness|
|16.5 – 22.5||Plush|
|22.5 – 26.5||Soft|
|26.5 – 30.5||Medium|
|30.5 – 34.5||Firm|
|34.5 – 38.5||Extra-firm|
Why ILD Ratings Aren’t Reliable
In my opinion?
Using ILD ratings alone to choose the right mattress firmness might backfire on you.
Because I consulted with several sources online to help me compile the ILD table above and they each said something different.
To me, it appears that whilst ILD ratings may indeed be objective by foam testing industry standards – this value could become lost in translation when trying to directly equate it to a mattress firmness and therefore gauge overall comfort.
For example, memory foam mattresses typically have different support and comfort layers that could have their own individual ILD ratings.
Put these together with any additional layers and two identical ILD ratings for two different brand mattresses could result in different real-world firmnesses.
Here’s a few more factors that could skew the relationship between ILD ratings and actual mattress firmness.
Comparing the ILD of memory foam mattresses and latex mattresses is like comparing apples and oranges.
Because the sample size for latex is around 152 mm compared to the normal 100 mm.
Matters are complicated further when you consider that brands like Tempur-Pedic have their own proprietary foam blends that make their Tempur-Pedic mattresses different to the other memory foam mattresses on the market.
The thicker the material layer being tested, the more force will be required to compress it to achieve a 25% indentation rate due to the effects of compounding.
So even if the sample size of the material used in the mattress is standardised at 100 mm for the ILD test – the actual thickness of the material that you’re going to be lying on in the mattress will vary.
Combine this with your body weight and sleeping position and ILD values start to become less meaningful in the real world in my view.
The apparent firmness of your foam mattress may decrease in the summer months.
Because an increase in temperature and humidity can make the material less dense and therefore skew the relationship between the original ILD value and the actual firmness.
Even if all ILD values mapped exactly to the same level of firmness – the final feel of the mattress would still differ because we are different weights.
For example, a 130 lb individual is likely to find that a mattress feels different to what a 230 lb person would think of the same mattress when lying on it – simply due to the difference in force being applied to the material.
In addition to your body weight, the position that you sleep in will affect how the mattress feels to you.
Sleeping on your side for example, increases the pressure on your hips and shoulders when compared to sleeping on your back or front – which tends to put more pressure on your lower back.
Simply switching between positions on the same mattress can give it a different feel regardless of its ILD rating.
How Can ILD Help You Choose the Right Mattress?
My final opinion on using ILD values to help you choose your ideal mattress goes against the grain of the other articles that I’ve read online:
I don’t think that ILD ratings are a good way to compare mattress firmnesses and potential comfort levels simply because the ratings can be skewed by so many variables.
Instead, I would encourage you to click the button below to find out how to best choose your ideal mattress based on more realistic factors such as your body weight and sleeping position.
Sources and References
 Wikipedia – Indentation Force Deflection. Accessed 30/12/19.
Dan is the founder and head content creator at Bedroom Style Reviews.
He has been working as a professional online product reviewer since 2015 and was inspired to start this website when he ended up sleeping on a memory foam mattress that was too soft and gave him backache.
Through in-depth research and analysis, Dan’s goal with this website is to help others avoid such pitfalls by creating the best online resource for helping you find your ideal mattress, bedding, and bedroom furniture.
Dan is a qualified NVQ Level 2 Fitness Instructor with 6 years’ experience helping clients improve their health through diet, exercise, and proper sleep hygiene.
He also holds several college and university-level qualifications in health sciences, psychology, mathematics, art, and digital media creation – which helps him to publish well researched and informative product reviews as well as articles on sleep, health, wellbeing, and home decor.
Dan also has direct personal experience with insomnia, anxiety, misophonia (hypersensitivity to sounds), and pain from both acute and long-standing sporting injuries – he enjoys writing insightful articles around these subjects to help fellow sufferers of such conditions.
Learn more about Dan here.