This page may contain affiliate links. This means that if you click a link and then buy a product from the linked vendor, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
This post has been quality checked in line with our Editorial and Research Policy.

7 Best Mattresses With a Free Sleep Trial to Buy in 2020

Top Pick: The Idle Hybrid

Free sleep trial lasts for 1.5 years.

Return for any reason at NO extra cost.

Lifetime warranty.

0% APR financing available to spread the cost.

Suitable for most sleeping positions and styles.

Double-sided for increased durability and longer lifespan.

Get 20% OFF the Idle Hybrid using the button below (limited time offer).

Idle Hybrid Mattress.

Did you know that lying on a mattress in the store for 5 minutes isn’t a good indicator of comfort?

Because it can take up to 30 days or more for a new mattress to fully ‘break in’ and adjust to your body weight, body type, and dominant sleeping position.

That’s why in addition to saving money, buying your mattress online is often the smarter move because you can also avail of a free ‘sleep trial’.

Where you can sleep in the mattress for a specified number of nights to ensure that you’re totally happy with your new mattress.

In contrast, many stores will actually void their return policy once you’ve slept in the mattress!

However, whilst the average sleep trial online is around 3 months, it’s actually better to go for a free trial that lasts at least 1 year.

Because in addition to covering you against minor sagging and body impressions that are not covered by the warranty, a 365 night trial allows you to test the mattress out for all 4 seasons to ensure that you’re comfortable in a range of temperatures (since some mattresses sleep hot).

Below, you’ll find a list of the best 7 mattresses that come with a free trial that lasts at least 1 year to make the selection process easier.

Just to be clear: a ‘free trial’ still requires you to pay for your mattress. The trial is more of a ‘risk free guarantee’ so that if you don’t like the mattress, you can return it and get your money back.

7 Best Mattresses With a Free Sleep Trial Reviewed

I’ve chosen the Idle Hybrid as the best mattress with a free trial because the 1.5 year sleep trial is the longest in the industry and the mattress itself is suitable for most sleeping positions and styles.

However, some of the other options that I’ve included in this list may interest you if you have more specific needs; such as sleeping cool, managing back pain, or trying to avoid wool.

I’ve also included some limited time discounts and offers to help you save some money.

Click the red buttons under each review to buy that mattress directly from the manufacturer and to get these offers before they expire.

1: Idle Hybrid – 1.5 Year Trial (Best Overall)

The Idle Hybrid Mattress
The Idle Hybrid Mattress (IdleSleep.com)

I have chosen the Idle Hybrid as the best mattress with a free trial overall because it has the longest sleep trial in the mattress industry and the qualities of the mattress makes it suitable for a wide range of sleeping styles.

More specifically, you can try out the Idle Hybrid for 1.5 years and return the mattress for ANY reason at NO extra cost to get a full monetary refund.

This means that you can sleep on the Idle Hybrid through all 4 seasons to ensure that you’re comfortable in a range of temperatures.

Also, because the free trial lasts for so long, it gives you the chance to return the mattress if any premature sagging or body impressions appear.

And this is a double-sided, hybrid spring-foam mattress available in medium, luxury firm, or medium on one side and luxury firm on the other – which means that it can accommodate front, back, and side sleepers in the average and heavier weight ranges.

Plus the strong edge support allows couples to make full use of the mattress area whilst the individually wrapped support coils and foam in the upper layers do a decent job of dampening movement so that you and your partner are less likely to wake each other up during the night.

And because the foam is specifically designed to be both cooling and responsive, this means that the Idle Hybrid will feel cooler and allow you to move around more easily when compared to a regular memory foam mattress.

Overall, I feel that the Idle Hybrid is an excellent choice that will suit most sleepers but also has the reassurance of the longest free trial in the mattress industry to cover you in the event of any problems.

And if you click the button below you can get 20% OFF the Idle Hybrid now for a LIMITED time only.

Recommended For

  • Side sleepers – the medium feel will likely suit side sleepers in the 150 – 230 lbs range, whilst heavier weighted sleepers over 230 lbs may prefer the luxury firm option to guard against sinkage (going for the medium/luxury firm double-sided option is probably the safest play). Lighter weighted side sleepers under 150 lbs may need to switch to the Idle Plush model to get the pressure relief that you need on your hips and shoulders.
  • Front sleepers – the Idle Hybrid is perfect for front sleepers because the springs and the medium/luxury firm feels can help to provide the support and surface tension that you need to keep your hips properly aligned when sleeping on your stomach.
  • Back sleepers – the medium level of firmness should suit back sleepers up to 230 lbs, whilst the luxury firm option can provide a touch more surface tension to combat sinkage if you weigh more than 230 lbs.
  • Restless sleepers – if you tend to shuffle around during the night then the proprietary Buoyancy Foam combined with the bounce of the springs can help you to switch positions more fluidly when compared to an all-foam polyfoam or memory foam mattress.
  • Heavier weighted sleepers – the support core consists of 1000 individually wrapped coils and combines perfectly with the medium/luxury firm feels to make the Idle Hybrid ideal for heavier weighted sleepers over 230 lbs that need more support and more surface tension to combat sinkage.
Idle Hybrid Medium Firmness Infographic.

Considerations

  • Lighter weighted/skinny sleepers – if you weigh less than 150 lbs and/or have a low body fat percentage (especially if you sleep on your side), then the Idle Hybrid may feel a little bit too firm for you. In which case the Idle Plush is a perfect alternative because the softer feel allows for greater pressure relief on the more prominent regions of your body like your shoulders and hips, whilst also allowing you to sink more deeply into the materials to dissipate the pressure from your joints.
  • 30 day minimum trial period – although the Idle Hybrid comes with an 18 month sleep trial, you’re not allowed to return the mattress before the first 30 days have elapsed because this is deemed to be the required ‘break in’ period.

More Benefits

  • Lifetime warranty – the Idle Hybrid also comes with a lifetime warranty that covers you against defects.
  • Longer lifespan (more value for money) – unlike most mattresses that are single sided, the double-sided design of the Idle Hybrid means that you can flip your mattress over to reduce the wear and tear and potentially increase the lifespan of your mattress, which helps to reduce the relative cost per night of sleep.
  • Free returns – if you need to return your mattress during the free sleep trial period then this will be done at no extra cost.
  • Non-toxic – in addition to using CertiPUR-US®️ foams to ensure that toxic chemicals like formaldehyde are absent and that odor emitting VOCs are kept to a minimum [1], the fire barrier is free from carcinogenic chemicals and is instead made from natural materials.
  • Get your money back – although exchanges are available if you wish, you’re eligible to get a full monetary refund if you need to return the Idle Hybrid.
  • 0% APR financing – if you click the button below, you can choose the option to pay for your new Idle Hybrid mattress on finance at the checkout at 0% APR to spread the cost and increase affordability.

2: Haven Boutique – 1.5 Year Trial (Best For Side Sleepers)

The Haven Boutique Mattress.
The Haven Boutique Mattress

The Idle Group – the parent company behind Idle Sleep – also own the Haven brand too [2].

And I’ve decided to include their Haven Boutique Mattress on this list of the best mattresses with a free trial because many of the benefits from the Idle brand carry over – including the 18 month sleep trial and the lifetime warranty.

However, the all-foam design, softer feel, and memory foam/gel foam top layers makes the Haven Boutique better for side sleepers than the Idle Hybrid because it moulds to your body shape more precisely to alleviate the pressure on your hips and shoulders more effectively.

Returns are simple and free of extra charges.

Recommended For

  • Side sleepers – the softer feel and memory foam top layers can provide excellent pressure relief on your hips and shoulders.
  • Lighter weighted sleepers – if you weigh less than 150 lbs then the deeper sinkage afforded by the foam can help to dissipate the pressure that typically builds up in your joints when lying on a firmer mattress with a lighter body weight.
  • Couples – the all-foam design is perfect for dampening movements and reducing noise that may otherwise result in night time disturbances.

Considerations

  • Front and back sleepers – although you will probably enjoy the Haven Boutique if you’re a front or back sleeper under 230 lbs and you prefer a softer mattress, you might be better going for the Haven Premier if you want a firmer mattress to help guard against sinkage (especially if you’re a stomach sleeper).
  • Heavier weighted sleepers – if you weigh more than 230 lbs, then you might also benefit from the firmer feel of the Haven Premier to guard against excessive sinkage.
  • 30 day minimum trial – much like the Idle Hybrid, the 18 month sleep trial that comes with the Haven Boutique stipulates that you must allow 30 days to pass before returning the mattress because this is the ‘break in’ period.

More Benefits

  • Cheaper than similar mattresses – the Haven Boutique is cheaper than many other mattress brands in the mid price range and has a much longer free trial period.
  • Lifetime warranty – the warranty covers you against defects including body impressions and sagging greater than 1 inch (better than the industry average of 1.5 inches).
  • Adjustable base available – if you’re looking for a mattress with an adjustable base then you can add one to your order as you checkout (along with memory foam pillows, luxury sateen bed sheets, and more accessories).
  • Save 20% – if you click the button below, you can get 20% off the Haven Boutique Mattress now for a limited time only.

3: DreamCloud Luxury Hybrid – 1 Year Trial (Most Affordable)

The DreamCloud Luxury Hybrid Mattress
The DreamCloud Luxury Hybrid Mattress (DreamCloudSleep.com)

If you’re looking to spread the cost of your mattress to increase affordability then I recommend taking a look at the DreamCloud Luxury Hybrid Mattress.

Because in addition to being able to get $200 OFF the regular asking price here (plus a free mattress protector and sheet set) for a limited time only, you can also potentially finance this mattress with 0% APR.

You can pre-qualify by selecting to pay through Affirm on the sales page, where you then may be offered the chance to spread the cost of the mattress over 3-12 months with no additional interest when the payments are made in full and on time.

And for further peace of mind, there’s a 1 year free trial to ensure that you can test the mattress through all 4 seasons, plus a lifetime warranty that protects you from defects and manufacturing flaws.

The mattress itself offers a blend of memory foam over individually wrapped coils to provide a balance of conforming pressure relief and adaptive support that will suit nearly every sleeping style.

Recommended For

  • Side sleepers – although this mattress is a touch on the firmer side, the memory foam and adaptive coils provide enough give to absorb the pressure points created by your hips and shoulders.
  • Front and back sleepers – the coils and the firmer feel can help to keep you in good posture when sleeping on your stomach or your back.
  • Heavier weighted sleepers – the robust support provided by the coils helps to offset the compression afforded by the memory foam to comfortably support heavier weights over 230 lbs.
  • Lighter weighted sleepers – even with the firmer feel, the memory foam does allow you to sink more deeply into the mattress if you weigh less than 150 lbs to help dissipate the compression forces in your joints.
  • Couples – the individually encased coils help to dissipate movements so that you are less likely to be woken by your partner as they sit on the edge of the bed or shuffle around during the night.

Considerations

  • 30 day minimum trial – for opened mattresses, you must allow for 30 days from the point of delivery before you can return your mattress to DreamCloud because this is the stipulated ‘break in’ period (however, this 30 day period is waived if you have NOT opened your mattress).
  • Open within 90 days – if you do not open the mattress within 90 days of delivery then the 365 night sleep trial (and the warranty) will be void.

More Benefits

  • Non-toxic foams – the foams are CertiPUR-US® certified to ensure that they do not contain certain toxic chemicals and have VOC counts that are kept to less than 0.5 parts per million to combat off-gassing (smells).
  • Strong edge support – the reinforced edges help to guard against sagging and roll-off.
  • Get $200 OFF (plus free gifts) – click the button below to save $200 on the DreamCloud Luxury Hybrid and get a free mattress protector and sheet set now (limited time offer – get it before it’s gone).

4: Level Sleep – 1 Year Trial (Best For Back Pain)

The Level Sleep Mattress
The Level Sleep Mattress (LevelSleep.com)

Shopping for a mattress to help with your back pain can be tricky.

Because back pain is a condition that is incredibly nuanced which means that there’s always the possibility that your new mattress doesn’t solve the problem (and may even make it worse).

That’s why I always recommend talking to your doctor before buying a mattress, bed, or sleep product for your specific health needs.

And I also advise that you go for a mattress with a lengthy and no-hassle return policy in the event that you’re not satisfied.

In which case the Level Sleep mattress could be well worth a look.

Because in addition to being covered by a 1 year free sleep trial, this mattress has been specifically designed to help combat back, hip, and joint pain through its zoned support and pressure relief system.

Where the foam surrounding your lower back is firmer to provide more support, whilst the regions under your shoulders and hips are softer to allow for better pressure relief on these more angular regions.

Furthermore, the Level Sleep mattress is endorsed by several chiropractors that vouch for its efficacy and is also supported by clinical trials that demonstrated that the Level Sleep mattress was able to help participants fall asleep faster and feel more refreshed during the day (see full details here).

If you would like to see more options, then have a look at my list of the best adjustable beds and mattresses for back pain here.

Recommended For

  • Those with musculoskeletal pain – the zoned support and pressure relief may help to alleviate the discomfort of several conditions that cause pain in your muscles and/or joints.
  • Athletes and active people – if you’re an athlete, runner, gym goer, or sporty person then you may be able to get a more rejuvenating night’s rest because the zoned support can help to reduce pressure points and improve circulation and blood perfusion that may lead to better recovery.
  • Side sleepers – the differing foam firmnesses are ideal for adapting to the contours of your body when you’re on your side to increase comfort.
  • Front and back sleepers – the adaptive support can help to promote better posture when you sleep on your front or your back.
  • Couples – if you sleep as a couple then you can enjoy the potential pain relieving benefits of the Level sleep mattress in the queen, king, and Cal. king sizes as well as the motion transfer isolation afforded by the all-foam design.

Considerations

  • Returns not available outside the US – only products shipped inside the US are eligible for returns.

More Benefits

  • Lifetime warranty – beats the industry average of 10 years.
  • Works with all bases – including box springs, divan bases, traditional frames, adjustable bases, platform bases, and even the floor.
  • 0% APR – apply at the checkout to pay through Affirm and you could be eligible to pay for your new Level Sleep mattress on 0% APR finance over 18 MONTHS to increase affordability (click the button below to learn more).

5: Awara – 1 Year Trial (Best For Sleeping Cool)

The Awara Mattress
The Awara Mattress (AwaraSleep.com)

If you tend to sleep warm then the hybrid spring-latex design of the Organic Luxury Awara Mattress can help to cool you down.

Because the Dunlop latex top layer has an aerated design that works with the spacious coil support core to promote airflow, dissipate heat, and regulate your temperature.

And because this mattress comes with a 1 year sleep trial, then you can try the mattress out for all 4 seasons to ensure that you’re comfortable in the Awara even in the hottest months.

Plus, there’s a lifetime warranty too.

This mattress should be suitable for most sleeping positions and styles because the luxury firm feel and the buoyant coils can provide support in the front and back sleeping positions, whilst the Euro top allows for deeper material compression in the side sleeping position to alleviate pressure points on your hips and shoulders.

And the inclusion of natural latex instead of polyfoam means that this mattress doesn’t contain chemicals, fire retardants, and allergens that may cause irritation in sensitive individuals.

Whilst the durable construct of the latex and the coils combine to create a very durable mattress that could last up to 10 years or more with the right care.

Recommended For

  • Warmer sleepers – the coils, natural latex, and organic New Zealand wool combine to dissipate heat and wick away moisture to help keep you cool and dry.
  • Side sleepers – the coils combine with the latex and the Euro top to provide pressure relief and support in the side sleeping position for average and heavier weighted side sleepers.
  • Front and back sleepers – the coils and firmer feel help to promote and maintain good posture when you’re sleeping on your front or back.
  • Restless sleepers – whilst the Euro top may help to actually soothe the pressure points that can lead to restlessness and allow you to get a deeper sleep, the bounce provided by the latex and the coils makes it easy to switch positions smoothly without getting bogged down in the materials.
  • Heavier weighted sleepers – if you weigh more than 230 lbs then the robust coils and durable latex comfort layer are ideal for supporting heavier weights and guarding against sinkage.
  • Couples – although latex doesn’t isolate movement quite as well as memory foam, it still does a fair job and the individually wrapped coils can help to dissipate shock waves to limit disturbance quite effectively.
  • Sensitive sleepers – the natural latex and absence of synthetic chemicals makes the Awara a good choice for sensitive sleepers like kids, the elderly, and allergy sufferers who are looking to limit reactions.

Considerations

  • 30 day minimum trial – although you can return this mattress up to 1 year later, you must wait 30 days from the point of delivery before being able to return the mattress.

More Benefits

  • Lifetime warranty – covers you against defects and manufacturing flaws.
  • Ideal for kids – the lack of polyfoams and chemicals complements the natural latex and organic New Zealand wool to create a kid-friendly sleeping surface.
  • Works with any frame – you can use the Awara with any frame that has a solid foundation; such as a slatted platform or adjustable frame.
  • 0% APR – pay with Affirm at the checkout for the opportunity to be able to pay off your mattress in monthly installments for up to 18 months at 0% APR to increase affordability.
  • Get $300 OFF – click the button below to get $300 OFF your new Awara mattress (for a limited time only).

6: Avocado Vegan – 1 Year Trial (Best Non-Wool Mattress)

The Avocado Vegan Mattress
The Avocado Vegan Mattress (AvocadoGreenMattress.com)

If you’re specifically looking to avoid a mattress with wool or any animal products then the Avocado Vegan Mattress is a great eco-friendly option.

Because in addition to using GOLS certified organic latex and GOTS certified organic cotton instead of synthetic polyfoams and wool, this mattress is also certified as being Vegan by Vegan Action and is also a PETA approved product.

This is a spring-latex hybrid mattress with a gentle firm feel and a 5-zoned coil support core that makes this mattress ideal for front and back sleepers.

However, you can also add a pillow top to give this mattress more pressure relieving qualities if you’re a side sleeper.

Plus, there’s a 1 year sleep trial available to cover you against any comfort issues or anything else that might cause you to want to return the mattress.

Recommended For

  • Front and back sleepers – the firmer feel and zoned support can help to keep you in good posture when you’re sleeping on your stomach or back.
  • Wool allergies – if you’re allergic to wool then the Avocado Vegan mattress is perfect because the wool has been replaced with organic cotton.
  • Heavier weighted sleepers – if you weigh more than 230 lbs then the coil core and durable latex combines with the firmer feel to provide the support that you’ll need to avoid sinking too far into the mattress.
  • Combination sleepers – the buoyant feel of the latex and springs makes it easier to switch positions when compared to a regular memory foam mattress that sinks in more.
  • Edge sleepers – if you tend to hug the edge of the bed as you sleep then the reinforced coil perimeter can help to combat sagging and roll-off.

Considerations

  • Side and lighter weighted sleepers – if you sleep on your side and/or you weigh less than 150 lbs then the addition of the pillow top might be the best move because it will provide more pressure relief.
  • No returns outside the US – the return and refund policy only applies to mattresses purchased in the continental United States.

More Benefits

  • Non-toxic – Avocado’s mattresses come with a range of certifications (including MADE SAFE®, STANDARD 100 by OEKO-TEX®, ECO-INSTITUT and GREENGUARD GOLD) that assure the mattress is absent from certain toxic chemicals.
  • Eco friendly and fair – Avocado is a Certified B Corporation® which means they have a legal responsibility to consider the impact of their business decisions on the environment, workers, customers, the community.
  • 0 % APR – pay with Affirm at the checkout for the possibility to pay for your new Avocado mattress at 0% APR over several months to increase affordability (click the button below to learn more).

7: Nectar Memory Foam – 1 Year Trial (Cheapest Mattress)

The Nectar Mattress (NectarSleep.com)
The Nectar Mattress (NectarSleep.com)

If the other options on this list are too expensive for you then the Nectar Memory Foam Mattress is the cheapest alternative that also comes with a generous 1 year free trial.

There’s also the option to pay on finance with Affirm at the checkout with 0% APR to increase affordability even further.

The Nectar mattress itself is well-rounded and should be suitable for most sleeping positions and styles.

More specifically, the slightly firmer feel is offset by the deeper compression capacity of the memory foam to provide sufficient support in the front and back sleeping positions, whilst side sleepers can still enjoy personalised pressure relief on their hips and shoulders.

And the motion dampening capabilities of the all-foam design makes this a great mattress for couples too.

Recommended For

  • Side sleepers – the pressure relieving qualities of the memory foam makes the Nectar ideal for softening the pressure points on your body in the side sleeping position.
  • Front and back sleepers – even though this is an all-foam mattress, the slightly firmer bias and high density foam base work together to promote good posture.
  • Couples – the lack of springs and all-foam design is ideal of dampening movements and noise.

Considerations

  • 30 day minimum trial – whilst unopened mattresses are eligible for immediate return and a refund, opened mattresses can only be returned after 30 days have elapsed after delivery.
  • Open within 90 days – if you don’t unbox your Nectar mattress within 90 days then the warranty and the sleep trial are void.

More Benefits

  • Lifetime warranty – get a replacement mattress in the first 10 years and repairs thereafter in the event of a defect.
  • Save $100 – to help you save even more money, when you click the button below, you can get $100 OFF your new Nectar mattress (plus 2 FREE pillows) for a limited time only.

How to Buy a Mattress With a Good Sleep Trial

A mattress with a free trial is one that comes with a ‘sleep trial’ so that you can sleep in the mattress for a specified number of nights to ensure that the mattress is comfortable for you – with options to return the mattress if you don’t like it.

A sleep trial differs from a mattress warranty because the warranty only covers you against defects and manufacturing faults, whilst the sleep trial also covers you against issues with comfort and anything else that could cause you to be unhappy with your mattress.

For example, if you slept on your mattress for a month and you found it to be too firm, too soft, or caused you back pain, then you wouldn’t be able to return the mattress under the warranty but you could return it under the terms of the sleep trial.

If you’re buying a mattress online (or even in store) a sleep trial is vital because it allows you to return the mattress in the event that you aren’t happy with it even AFTER you have slept on it.

This is important because many high street stores and shops WON’T allow you to return the mattress once you’ve slept on it.

Therefore, sleep trials that remain valid even when you’ve slept in the bed – coupled with the lower prices (due to less middle men that typically make mattress more expensive) – are the two primary driving forces that make buying a mattress online better than going through a physical store.

Below is a quick summary of the benefits and drawbacks of a sleep trial, followed by a 3 step guide that walks you through the process of buying a mattress with a good sleep trial.

Mattress Firm’s 120-Night Sleep Trial (Mattress Firm)

Benefits

Most people don’t realise that it can take up to 30 successive nights of sleeping in your mattress for it to ‘break in’ and adjust to your body weight, body type, and dominant sleeping position.

Which is why lying on a mattress in the store for a few minutes is actually a very poor gauge of comfort – as I can personally vouch for having discovered that a memory foam mattress that was initially very comfortable transformed into some sort of torture device after the foam had softened and failed to support my lower back correctly.

And as mentioned previously, some physical stores sell their mattresses WITHOUT a returns policy – which means that you could be stuck with an expensive mattress that you hate.

Therefore, the biggest advantage of a sleep trial from an online DTC (direct to consumer) mattress manufacturer that lasts at least 30-60 nights is that it covers you against discomfort beyond the break in period – so that you can return the mattress if you’re uncomfortable after the materials have adjusted to your sleeping style even after you’ve slept in it.

In terms of duration, the industry average for sleep trials is around 3 months – which is long enough to cover the adjustment phase and also some premature sagging.

The sleep trial can also allow you to return your mattress if you find that it sleeps too hot (a problem with some memory foam mattresses), causes allergies, doesn’t have enough edge support, is too noisy, allows for too much motion transfer (resulting in you and your partner waking each other up as you move around); is too hard, too soft, or too difficult to move around in – pretty much anything that upsets you.

Drawbacks

The biggest drawback to sleep trials is that they often come with a MINIMUM trial period too – usually 30 nights.

Which means that you could be forced to sleep on your new mattress for up to a month or more before you’re allowed to return it.

This might not a be a problem if you have somewhere else to sleep, but you could end up in some serious discomfort if you don’t.

However, if you’ve not opened your mattress, then most companies will allow you to return the mattress right away.

Another thing to watch out for is hidden charges and shipping fees that you might have to pay for if you want to return the mattress.

Some companies may force you to try and hang on to the mattress by sending you different comfort layers to alter the firmness and feel of the mattress – this might work, or it might drag out the return process even longer.

One more overlooked issue to think about is the conflict that may arise if you buy a mattress on finance and then have to return it – since the finance company and the mattress seller are typically two different entities; which means that you may have problems trying to cancel payments and avoid paying interest in the event of a return.

However, this isn’t a certainty, and buying a mattress on a 0% APR deal might be the best way to avoid interest in the event of a return (but you should check the terms of the finance agreement and the return policy to be sure).

And finally, if you’re buying a mattress from a retail or auction site online, then you need to check that it’s being provided by the manufacturer or an authorised seller.

Because when dealing with an unauthorised 3rd party, the manufacturer’s sleep trial and warranty is typically void – with returns usually being subject to a different agreement (or none at all).

So before buying the mattress, it’s important that you check the fine print of the return policy to ensure that you’re aware of any hidden fees and stipulations that could cause problems in the future.

1: Go For a Trial that Lasts at Least 1 Year

Most DTC online mattress companies offer sleep trials in the region of 90 – 120 nights.

And whilst this duration is likely plenty long enough for most folks, I actually suggest going for a mattress with a free trial that lasts for a MINIMUM of 1 YEAR.

Why?

Because this length of time allows you to sleep in your mattress through all 4 seasons so that you can ensure that you’re comfortable in a range of different temperatures.

This is especially important if you’re buying a memory foam mattress because this type of material is the most likely to cause heat retention issues.

Whilst the longer duration will allow you to ensure that the cooling capabilities of the gel foam, gel beads, aerated foams, or other features that often come with high quality memory foam mattresses to combat heat retention and regulate your temperature have not stopped working (which is often the case with the gel foam layers in some poor quality gel memory foam mattresses).

And the extended length of the sleep trial can also cover you from sagging and body impressions that appear prematurely and are not covered by the warranty (buying a mattress with good support can help to guard against sagging).

2: Look at the Terms

It’s very important that you look beyond the length of the sleep trial and look at the exact terms of the return policy to ensure that you’re clear on the details.

If you scroll to the bottom of a mattress company’s website, you’ll usually be able to read the terms in full by clicking on the ‘return policy’ or ‘FAQ’ link.

Or you can contact their customer support via live chat or a contact form for additional clarification.

The two key areas that you need to pay attention to are the money back policy and any hidden costs.

Money Back Policy

Make sure that the return policy states that you’re entitled to a full monetary refund and not just an exchange or a ‘comfort layer exchange’.

Because whilst an exchange may solve the issue, you should also be in a position to get all of your money back without delay if you hate the mattress and/or the company and don’t want an exchange.

Hidden Costs

You’ll want to ensure that you can return your mattress without having to pay for return shipping or a pick up fee.

Pay particular attention to the locations that the terms of the sleep trial apply to because if you’ve ordered your mattress from a different country or a specified location then you may be subject to additional charges.

For example, if you’re ordering a mattress online from the US but you live in Alaska, Hawaii, Canada or somewhere else outside the US, then you’ll likely find that returning your mattress could cost you $100’s extra in return shipping.

Ordering from a certain location may also void the free trial.

3: Choose the Right Mattress

Even though a good quality sleep trial can protect you from ending up with a mattress that you don’t like, it’s worth taking the time to consider the firmness, design, and preferences of the mattress before you order it to lessen the chance of ending up with an unsuitable mattress.

Firmness

Mattresses are available in a range of different firmnesses – which influences how hard or soft the mattress feels when you lie down on it.

For front, back, and side sleepers in the 130 – 230 lbs range (around 80% of sleepers), a medium/universal firmness is usually just fine.

But if you weigh less than 150 lbs and/or have a low body fat percentage (especially if you’re a side sleeper) then a softer level of firmness may be more suitable because the reduced surface tension can allow you to sink further into the materials and alleviate pressure points on your body.

Firmer mattresses tend to be better for heavier weighted sleepers over 230 lbs and/or front sleepers because the increased surface tension can help to guard against excessive sinkage and maintain good posture.

Support

The support of a mattress is the degree to which the mattress is able to keep you in good posture and support your spine and joints.

And whilst the firmness can have some influence, its the lower support core that primarily dictates the quality of the support and is a product of the design of the mattress – including the quality and integrity of the materials.

All types of mattresses can have ‘good’ or ‘bad’ support, but springs and high density latex foam tend to provide better support than low density polyfoam in the support core.

Design

The main types of mattresses and their suitability are as follows:

  • Memory foam – memory foam mattresses typically have a layer of mid or high density memory foam over a layer of high density polyfoam or springs (hybrid). The spring core is generally better for heavier weighted sleepers, whilst the all-foam design can help to dampen movements so that couples can sleep undisturbed. Mattresses with a memory foam top layer are ideal for side sleepers because the adaptive nature of the memory foam helps to remove pressure points on your hips and shoulders.
  • Polyfoam – mattresses that consist entirely of memory foam are some of the cheapest but are the most likely to sag and wear out. With cheap foam mattresses, you need to be wary that fiberglass isn’t contained under the cover because if released, this substance can harm your health and be very costly to remove from your home.
  • Latex – latex mattresses are similar to memory foam mattresses except they tend to be more durable, more cooling, longer lasting, better at combating allergies (like dust mite sensitivities), less likely to contain fiberglass, more bouncy, and are suitable for just about every type of sleeper.
  • Hybrid – hybrid mattresses have a spring support core that can provide excellent support and cooling capabilities (by encouraging airflow) whilst also leveraging the properties of a latex or memory foam comfort layer in line with your choosing. Hybrid mattresses are some of the best and most adaptive types of mattresses that you can buy – suitable for just about every sleeping style through various layering and material configurations.
  • Innerspring – innerspring mattresses have a spring core an an upholstered top layer; making them potentially cheaper than hybrid mattresses but potentially not as long-lasting.

Preferences

Beyond the primary design of the mattress, you may like to consider the following secondary preferences to potentially increase the satisfaction of your purchase:

  • Features for couples – if you sleep as a couple then motion isolation should be considered. All-foam and spring mattress with individually wrapped pocket coils do the best job of dampening movements overall.
  • Cooling features – if you sleep hot then hybrid and all-latex mattresses are the most breathable. Memory foam tends to retain the most amount of heat; although cooling gel foams and aerated foam structures can help to combat this.
  • Allergy control – if you’re allergic to dust mites, have sensitive skin, or are liable to react to toxins or other allergens, then organic latex mattresses are the best choice. If you’re allergic to latex then memory foam or a hypoallergenic mattress with the latex proteins removed could work.
  • Edge support – if you sleep near the edge of the bed then look for a hybrid mattress with reinforced coils around the edges, or a foam mattress with higher density foam around the perimeter.

Related Questions

Although I’ve covered the main points, here’s a few concise answers to the most common questions that relate to mattresses and sleep trials (also known as ‘free trials’).

What’s the Difference Between a Sleep Trial and a Warranty?

A sleep trial allows you to return your mattress for a much wider range of reasons – such as problems with the comfort levels – whilst a warranty is restricted to defects and manufacturing flaws; such as broken components like springs and zippers or sagging above a certain depth (typically 1-1.5″).

Do All Mattresses Come With a Sleep Trial?

Not all mattresses come with a sleep trial. Many mattresses bought on the high street do not come with a sleep trial – or even a return policy that’s still valid after you’ve slept in the mattress. However, most mattresses sold online via DTC mattress companies come with a sleep trial that’s valid after you’ve slept in the mattress.

What’s the Longest Free Trial for a Mattress?

The longest sleep trial currently offered is 1.5 years (18 months) by Idle Sleep and its associated brand Haven.

What’s the Best Mattress With a Free Trial?

The best mattress with a sleep trial is the Idle Hybrid because the free trial lasts for 1.5 years and the mattress has the right qualities to suit a wide range of sleeping positions and styles.

Click the button below to get 20% OFF the Idle Hybrid mattress for a limited time.


Sources and References

[1] CertiPUR-US®️ – Foams. Accessed 9/8/20.

[2] PR Newswire – Idle Group Expands Portfolio: Leading Direct-to-Consumer Mattress Company Launches New Brand Haven, Acquires Mend Sleep. Accessed 9/8/20.

Leave a comment