If you’re thinking of buying a Vesgantti hybrid mattress then you might be wondering if you should get the pillow top or the tight top version.
The Vesgantti Pillow Top mattress is best for side sleepers and lighter weighted sleepers under 150 lbs due to the extra cushioning that can help to provide pressure relief on your shoulders and help dissipate your body weight more evenly, whilst the firmer tight top is better for front and back sleepers overall.
The rest of this article reviews the Vesgantti Pillow Top and Tight Top mattresses in more detail to help you decide which model is right for your needs.
Alternatively: if you don’t want to buy either of the Vesgantti mattresses, then click here to see the best mattresses to buy online in 2021 now for some excellent alternatives.
Vesgantti Mattress Reviews
To sum it up, both versions of this Vesgantti hybrid mattress offer very good pressure relief, contoured support, and cooling capabilities.
However, the extra cushioning makes the pillow top the better choice for side sleepers and other sleeping positions if you’re under 150 lbs.
Conversely, the extra firmness provided by the tight top makes it better for front and back sleepers over 150 lbs.
But the 200 lbs weight limit for each model in the single sleeper sizes makes this a poor choice for heavier weighted sleepers.
Although the excellent edge support and motion transfer isolation makes this a good choice for suitably weighted couples below the 400 lbs collective limit in the queen size.
Check out my full Vesgantti mattress review below for a more detailed breakdown – or see my top rated mattress reviews if you’re in need of an alternative.
Vesgantti Design Analysis
Although structured slightly differently, both the 10.6 inch pillow top and the 9.5 inch tight top provide a very similar combination of pressure relief and support to provide contoured comfort that’s going to appeal to a wide range of sleepers.
The main difference is that the pillow top will feel softer than the tight top.
And for two relatively thin mattresses, I was surprised to find that each model comprises of a complex, multi-layered design that’s reflective of a high quality mattress that’s been designed very thoughtfully and executed upon with effective precision.
Here’s a detailed breakdown of the primary layers of each mattress.
1) Pillow Top
The pillow top version of the Vesgantti hybrid is topped with an additional layer that gives this otherwise medium mattress a softer feel with more cushioning and pressure relief.
2) Tight Top
The tight top version of the Vesgantti hybrid lacks the additional padding provided by the pillow top – making it feel firmer by comparison.
3) Comfort Layer
The 10.6 inch pillow top is topped by a stretchy comfort cover and breathable cotton layer that gives way to a section of egg crate cooling foam that improves air circulation and adjusts to your individual body shape to relieve pressure and increase comfort.
The 9.5 inch tight top achieves a similar blend of cooling comfort and targeted pressure relief by combining a comfort stretch cover with egg crate foam, breathable foam, and Vesgantti® Comfort foam.
4) Support Core
The support core for the 10.6 inch pillow top begins with the Vesgantti® Comfortable Hybrid Transition Layer which provides contoured support and works with the subsequent Vesgantti® Icoil support core that dynamically adjusts to your shape to cradle your spine and joints to keep you comfortable.
The 9.5 inch tight top provides a similar level of adaptive support through the same Icoil layer that’s topped with several Vesgantti®Pressure Relief Foam Layers which also helps to enhance the pressure relieving qualities of the upper comfort layers.
Vesgantti Performance Analysis
To sum it up, I think both models provide equally excellent levels of comfort, support, and cooling capabilities for a very reasonable price.
See below for more details.
Both models have a medium level of firmness.
However, the pillow top has a plusher feel.
This means that when you lie on it, you’ll first notice how soft it feels as the pillow top envelops your body but this will give way to an underlying firmness that will help to keep you supported in the mattress.
The tight top will provide the same kind of support, but it won’t feel as soft.
But the final feel of either mattress ultimately depends on your body weight, body shape, and your dominant sleeping position – more on this in the upcoming comfort analysis section.
2) Pressure Relief
Both models provide a good level of pressure relief on the more prominent areas of your body thanks to their upper comfort layers that contain lower density foams that contour to your body shape.
However, the added cushioning provided by the pillow top maximises the amount of pressure relief because the added layer of material sinks in more when compared to the harder tight top.
This means that if you’re a side sleeper and/or have very prominent bones and joints then the pillow top is probably going to be the better choice for you because it will provide the maximum amount of pressure relief to maximise your comfort levels.
Sleeping on your back typically doesn’t require the same level of pressure relief because your body weight is naturally distributed more evenly over the mattress area and so the added firmness of the tight top may be the better choice because it will also help to keep your hips aligned to guard against back pain.
Both models provide excellent support because they share the same Vesgantti® Icoil core which leverages the adaptability of individually wrapped coils to provide dynamic support for your spine and joints whilst the transition layer works to stop you from feeling the coils pressing into you.
However, I think that the tight top has the slight edge when it comes to providing the maximum level of support in the front and back sleeping positions because the added surface tension can further help with keeping your hips aligned and your lower back protected from bad posture.
4) Moving Around
Moving around and sitting up in either model is going to be pretty easy if you’re under 200 lbs because of the strong support core.
However, if maximum mobility is a key requirement for you then the tight top will provide the most amount of surface tension to guard against sinkage and lacks the extra padding of the pillow top which may otherwise bog you down.
Both models are fair choices if you’re looking for a quiet mattress because they each use individually wrapped coils which can guard against the creaks, groans, and ‘pings’ that are typical of innerspring beds that use a solid coil core.
However, you’ll need to ensure that your bed frame is in good shape and well put together because movements are likely to pass through these relatively thin mattresses quite easily which can result in unwanted sounds.
6) Maximum Weight Capacity
The maximum weight capacity for either model is quite low at 200 lbs for the single sleeper sizes and 400 lbs total for the queen.
If you sleep as a couple then both mattresses are reasonable choices in my view.
Because the individually wrapped coils can help to minimise the feelings of your bed partner moving around during the night.
However, the largest size that I could find either mattress in was a queen – which gives you a maximum of 6.6 feet in length and 5 feet in width to work with.
And you’ll need to check that you BOTH have sleeping styles that are compatible with either the tight top OR the pillow top – see the upcoming comfort analysis section for more guidance on this.
8) Edge Support
One of the great things about both models is that they come with specifically reinforced edges.
This means that you can make full use of the mattress area – which is great if you’re a couple so that you can spread out more, or an edge sleeper because you’ll be able to hug the edge of the bed without rolling out.
And the reinforced foam combines with the already robust support springs to guard against excessive sinkage when you’re getting in and out of bed.
If you have sensitive skin then the use of CertiPUR-US® foams may be beneficial for you because this certification ensures that certain harmful chemicals like formaldehyde aren’t used  – which may otherwise cause irritation.
10) Temperature Regulation
Both models should help you to sleep cool because several layers of the mattress are specifically designed to improve airflow and dissipate heat – such as the cover, egg crate foam, and transition layer.
Both Vesgantti mattresses stand out because they also have dedicated cotton and non-woven fabric layers that are interspaced throughout the depth of the entire mattress profile to enhance airflow.
This contrasts with many other hybrid beds that only have dedicated cooling layers in the upper comfort layers.
So if you’re a hot sleeper then I think you’ll be happy with the cooling capabilities of both Vesgantti mattress models.
11) Keeping You Dry
The superior air flow can help you to stay dry and the cover does have some moisture wicking properties.
But if you’re a very sweaty sleeper then make sure that you buy a set of cooling bamboo bed sheets because they are great at absorbing moisture and pushing it to the edge of the sheet where it can evaporate – instead of drenching like cotton tends to do.
The low VOC count and anti-bacterial properties of the cover should help to combat odours both in the long and short term.
13) Pain Management
The softer pillow top may help to take away the pressure on key areas like your shoulders to help with muscular pains.
Whilst the firmer feel of the tight top and dynamic support can help with managing back pain because of the better hip position, whilst the spring positioning has the capacity to help with gently elongating your vertebrae to enhance decompression and reduce disc related pain – similar to how the Magniflex MagniStretch mattress performs but without the use of angled foam.
14) Cleaning and Maintenance
I don’t think you can remove the cover – so make sure that you’re using a high quality sheet set to help protect your mattress from damage and to make cleaning easier.
15) Price v Value
Both models are very competitively priced and I think that you get a lot of value in return for your money.
Vesgantti Comfort Analysis
The 200 lbs weight limit puts a tight upper limit on the single sleeper sizes.
But as a rule, the lighter you are and the skinnier your body type then the more pressure relief you’ll require – making the pillow top the best choice.
And you should go for the tight top if you’re on the heavier side because the added firmness will provide better support in the upper comfort layers to help keep your hips properly aligned.
See below for the exact breakdown for each sleeping position and body weight range.
1) Front Sleepers
If you’re a font sleeper then your primary concern is keeping your hips aligned to prevent back pain whilst also getting enough pressure relief on your elbows and knees whilst having the right amount of sinkage so that your neck isn’t put under a lot of pressure.
As a lighter sleeper, you’re going to sit more on top of the materials which increases firmness – so I’d recommend going for the pillow top if you’re a stomach sleeper in the 100 lbs – 150 lbs range so you can benefit from the extra pressure relief that comes with the added padding.
If you’re in the 150 lbs – 200 lbs range then you’ll need more support so I’d go for the tight top so that the added surface tension can help to keep your hips and spine nicely aligned.
2) Back Sleepers
You can get away with a little bit more sinkage as a back sleeper but I’d still recommend the pillow top for the 100 lbs – 150 lbs range and the tight top for the 150 lbs – 200 lbs range to get the right balance of comfort and support.
3) Side Sleepers
Side sleepers need more pressure relief and greater capacity for material sinkage so that the pressure goes through the mattress more and less though your joints.
So I’d recommend going for the pillow top if you’re a side sleeper in the 100 lbs – 200 lbs range and skip the tight top completely.
4) Combo Sleepers
As a combination sleeper who switches positions often during the night, you’ll probably prefer the tight top because the added surface tension will allow you to move around without getting trapped in the materials.
However, if you’re a combination sleeper with a side sleeping bias then you might need the extra padding provided by the pillow top for greater pressure relief.
5) Edge Sleepers
Either model is a great choice if you’re an edge sleeper because the reinforced edges will allow you to wrap yourself around the edge of the bed without the increased risk of roll-off.
Which Model is the Most Durable?
Due to their similar construction and layered design, both versions of the Vesgantti should be pretty durable due to their strong support structure.
Although you may find that the tight top is more resilient to wear and tear than the pillow top due to the absence of the extra padding.
Which Model is the Least Likely to Sag?
As long as you’re not exceeding the weight limit then I don’t think that either model is at risk of sagging prematurely because of the robust support core and durable upper layers.
What Are the Compatible Frames?
Either model will work with slatted, platform, or box foundations.
You can use the floor too but it will make the mattress feel even firmer due to the relatively thick profiles.
Can You Flip Either Mattress?
You shouldn’t flip either model because this would mean that you’ll end up sleeping on the more uncomfortable base layers.
Is There a Sleep Trial?
Depending on the retail site that you order from, you may be able to avail of Vesgantti’s 100 night sleep trial.
Is There a Warranty?
Both models are covered by a 10 year limited warranty.
- Pillow top for more pressure relief – resulting in more comfort for side and lighter weighted sleepers.
- Tight top for greater firmness and mobility – better for heavier weighted front, back, and combo sleepers.
- Sleeps cool thanks to the multiple cooling layers that are interspaced throughout the mattress profile in both models.
- The moisture wicking cover helps to keep you dry.
- Great edge support to stop you from rolling out and to ease the process of getting in and out of bed.
- Anti-microbial cover helps to inhibit mold growth for a more hygenic mattress.
- 200 lbs upper weight limit for the single sleeper sizes.
Here are my final ratings out of 5 for both Vesgantti mattress models.
|Value vs Price
Who Should Buy the Vesgantti Pillow Top?
- Hot sleepers looking to stay cool.
- 100 lbs – 150 lbs front and back sleepers.
- 100 lbs – 200 lbs side sleepers.
- 100 lbs – 200 lbs side-dominant combo sleepers.
- 100 lbs – 150 lbs edge sleepers.
Who Should Avoid the Vesgantti Pillow Top?
- All sleepers over 150 lbs – except side sleepers.
Who Should Buy the Vesgantti Tight Top?
- Hot sleepers looking to stay cool.
- 150 lbs – 200 lbs front and back sleepers.
- 150 lbs – 200 lbs front and back dominant combo sleepers.
- 150 lbs – 200 lbs edge sleepers.
Who Should Avoid the Vesgantti Tight Top?
- All sleepers under 150 lbs.
What Are the Alternatives?
I hope that my Vesgantti mattress reviews have helped you to decide if the pillow top or the tight top version is right for you.
But if you’re still in need of some further options then click the button below.
Sources and References
 CertiPUR-US® – Overview. Accessed 13/4/20.
Dan is the founder and head content creator at Bedroom Style Reviews.
He has been working as a professional online product reviewer since 2015 and was inspired to start this website when he ended up sleeping on a memory foam mattress that was too soft and gave him backache.
Through in-depth research and analysis, Dan’s goal with this website is to help others avoid such pitfalls by creating the best online resource for helping you find your ideal mattress, bedding, and bedroom furniture.
Dan is a qualified NVQ Level 2 Fitness Instructor with 6 years’ experience helping clients improve their health through diet, exercise, and proper sleep hygiene.
He also holds several college and university-level qualifications in health sciences, psychology, mathematics, art, and digital media creation – which helps him to publish well researched and informative product reviews as well as articles on sleep, health, wellbeing, and home decor.
Dan also has direct personal experience with insomnia, anxiety, misophonia (hypersensitivity to sounds), and pain from both acute and long-standing sporting injuries – he enjoys writing insightful articles around these subjects to help fellow sufferers of such conditions.
Learn more about Dan here.